- The government is worried because the number of people without job is increasing.
Betul tidak kalimatnya? Seharusnya increases or is increasing?
Please help. Thanks beforehand.
Betul tidak kalimatnya? Seharusnya increases or is increasing?
Please help. Thanks beforehand.
7 comments
Swara Bhaskara
October 18, 2011
Hi Julia,
Both sentences are grammatically correct, but are both contextually correct?
The “is increasing” expresses that the increase is in progress at present and the speaker wants to stress on that progress. (Jumlah orang yang tidak punya pekerjaan SEDANG MENINGKAT dan ini membuat pemerintah khawatir). It makes sense to me.
Hmm… I’d replace the because with when or the like to make the sentence suitable in the simple present tense but it will change the sentence meaning, as well.
zen
November 13, 2011
If I write this one : The government is worried because increasing the number of people without job. how is it? thanks beforehand. I don’t intend to make you confuse.
Swara Bhaskara
November 13, 2011
There is no verb after “because“, so here we can use “because of“.
julia
October 18, 2011
thanks for the help sir..
how about this one
“what are you thinking about my idea?”
or
“what do you think about my idea?”
I personally think the second one is suitable, but I can’t explain why..
could you please give an explanation about this sir?Â
Swara Bhaskara
October 18, 2011
Increase is an active verb while think, depending on the context, can be an active verb or a stative one. When you say, “Menurut kamu ideku bagaimana?“, you’re actually asking the person you’re talking to about his or her perception about your idea. The person doesn’t need to use his or her energy to respond you. The person will just reply you by what he or she perceives. In this case, think is a stative verb and it should never be in a progressive form.
On the other hand, if you say,
then think is an active verb because there’s an action. Here, energy is needed and sometimes it’s followed by the falling off your hair.
In this case, it can be used in any tense.
For a more detailed discussion, please see “Simple Present tense vs Present continuous tense“.
julia
October 18, 2011
I see… I understand now.
yeah, I check that link already, and it gave me solution for my two questions…
thanks for your time sir.. Â
zen
November 13, 2011
thanks Mr.